Guardianship, Supported Decision Making, and Power of Attorney: What Are the Differences and Which Option Is Right for Me?

November 20, 2026 | Lauren I. Mechaly | Sarah Natanov | Trusts & Estates

Parents often seek advice on how to support their disabled child in his or her decision making once they turn 18. There are three options, depending on the child’s level of disability. If the young adult can make decisions independently but lacks the confidence to do so, supported decision making may be appropriate. Similarly, the young adult may have the capacity to make certain financial or legal decisions but lacks the experience or knowledge to do so. In that case, a Power of Attorney that names the parents as agents may be the right option. However, if these less-restrictive alternatives are unavailable or inadequate to meet the young adult’s needs, guardianship may be appropriate.

Understanding the differences among these options can help individuals and their families choose the plan that provides the appropriate level of protection and fosters independence.

Supported Decision Making

Supported decision making allows a disabled individual to receive assistance in making decisions while retaining the autonomy to make decisions independently.

Under a supported decision-making arrangement, the individual picks a trusted supporter who will help gather information, explain available options, communicate choices, and provide appropriate resources to the individual. The purpose of the arrangement is to help the individual understand the choices presented and make an informed decision. Supported decision making preserves the individual’s autonomy because the decision-making authority is not transferred to another person.

This arrangement may be particularly beneficial for individuals who retain decision-making capacity but need guidance in understanding or communicating their choices. By allowing the individual to remain actively involved in the decision-making process, supported decision making can promote independence and self-determination. A supporter does not become a substitute decision maker and ordinarily cannot sign documents, consent to treatment, or conduct transactions on the individual’s behalf merely because of the supportive relationship. Instead, the supporter helps the individual exercise the individual’s own decision-making ability.

Although supported decision making has not yet been formally codified in New Jersey, professionals continue to advocate for its use. As a result, the practical effect of an arrangement may depend on the setting and on the willingness of a financial institution, health care provider, or other third party to work with the supporter.

Power of Attorney

A general durable Power of Attorney is a legal document that grants broad authority to the agent (also referred to as an attorney-in-fact) to act on the principal’s behalf with respect to financial and/or legal matters. Provided that the Power of Attorney includes the statutory language from NJ Rev Stat § 46:2B-8.2 (2025), the authority granted by the principal will continue despite his or her incapacity. Once signed, the agent has immediate authority to act, and when drafted as a durable Power of Attorney, the authority granted remains effective even if the principal later becomes incapacitated. The authority granted may be broadly or narrowly tailored to meet the principal’s needs.

The principal can also “turn on” the Power of Attorney at a triggering event, such as a determination of incapacity by a medical professional. This is called a “springing” Power of Attorney, and it authorizes the agent to act only when the triggering event has occurred.

Signing a Power of Attorney does not restrict the principal from making his or her own decisions while he or she still has capacity to do so. However, the agent’s authority to act is immediate, unless the document says otherwise.

To execute a valid Power of Attorney, the principal must be at least 18 years old and be able to understand the nature and consequences of appointing an agent. This means that the young adult must understand what he or she is signing and what it means to have someone else acting on their behalf. Of course, the young adult must also instruct the drafting attorney as to the appointment of the agent, and whether there are any limitations they wish to include in the document. For example, are they appointing an agent to represent them in a particular real estate matter, or are they limiting the agent’s authority to make gifts?

Although an agent has a duty to act in the principal’s best interests, granting financial authority can create opportunities for misuse or abuse if the wrong person is appointed. That is why it is important for the principal to appoint a trusted agent to step into this role.

If the individual is able and willing to sign a Power of Attorney, he or she should also sign a Health Care Proxy to appoint an agent to make medical decisions in the event of incapacity. The agent named in the Health Care Proxy may be the same person named in the Power of Attorney, but it does not have to be.

Guardianship

If an individual lacks capacity and no less-restrictive arrangement can adequately address the young adult’s needs, an application for guardianship may be necessary. Guardianship is a legal process in which the court determines an individual’s capacity to make his or her own decisions. In New Jersey, guardianships are governed by N.J.S.A. 3B:12-24.1 and N.J.S.A. 3B:12-36. If the court determines, based on doctors’ certifications and a hearing, that the individual is incapacitated, the court will appoint a legal guardian.

Because the appointment of a guardian significantly restricts an individual’s autonomy, it is considered the most restrictive form of intervention, and courts will tailor the guardian’s authority to meet the individual’s needs. An application to the court can be for the guardianship of the person (i.e. health care decision making), guardianship of the property (i.e. financial decision making) or both.

In New Jersey, guardianship applications require medical evidence to support the alleged incapacitated person’s disability, decision-making abilities, and limitations. This includes certifications or affidavits from two physicians, or from one physician and one licensed psychologist. The inquiry should focus not merely on a diagnosis, but on the decisions the individual can and cannot make, the assistance already available, and whether a less-restrictive alternative can meet the individual’s needs.

A guardianship proceeding is time-consuming and expensive, involving court filing fees, professional evaluations, and legal expenses, and it may significantly impact the individual’s autonomy. It is a lengthy, involved process, and should only be pursued if less restrictive alternatives are unavailable or inadequate.

Advanced planning can reduce the likelihood that court intervention will later become necessary. Individuals who have capacity should execute a valid Power of Attorney and Health Care Proxy before court intervention is required. Of course, this is not always possible, and parents should be mindful to begin the process early enough so that a legal representative can be appointed as soon as the individual turns 18.

Ultimately, every family needs to make the decision that is best for them. The appropriate approach depends on the individual’s abilities, needs, and existing support network. Supported decision making preserves decision-making authority while providing assistance; a Power of Attorney allows a capable adult to delegate specified legal or financial authority; and guardianship transfers authority by court order, when necessary. As is the case with all planning, there is no one-size-fits-all answer, so individuals and families should consider the person’s circumstances and available alternatives, and seek appropriate legal guidance, before deciding which path to pursue.

Reprinted with permission from the November 20, 2026, issue of the New Jersey Law Journal. © 2026 ALM Global Properties, LLC. All rights reserved. Further duplication without permission is prohibited, contact 877-256-2472 or asset-and-logo-licensing@alm.com.

 

Share this article:

Related Publications