OB/GYN Practice Liable to Patient for Breach of Confidentiality
January 7, 2019 | Eric D. Fader | HIPAA | Legislation and Public Policy | LitigationA Connecticut state court ruled in December that an obstetrics and gynecology practice must pay a former patient close to $2 million, the latest round in an 11-year saga in which the case was appealed to the state Supreme Court twice. The defendant medical practice was found to have breached the confidentiality of the plaintiff’s medical records by releasing information about her pregnancy without her authorization.
The plaintiff in the long-running case, Emily Byrne, had instructed Avery Center for Obstetrics and Gynecology, P.C., not to release the records of her prenatal care to her former boyfriend, the father of the baby. However, when the Westport practice received a subpoena from the father in a paternity action, it sent a copy of Byrne’s records to the court without giving her prior notice or requesting the court’s guidance regarding its obligations under HIPAA.
Byrne’s claims were brought under Connecticut common law. The lower court originally ruled in November 2014 that her negligence claims were preempted by HIPAA, under which there is no private right of action, and dismissed them. However, the state Supreme Court reversed the trial court’s decision, finding that a HIPAA violation may be actionable under state law to the extent that it constitutes a violation of generally accepted standards of care.
In January 2018, on appeal for the second time, the Supreme Court reversed the trial court’s grant of summary judgment for the defendant on two counts, negligence and infliction of emotional distress. The lower court had found that the Avery Center owed Byrne no common-law duty of confidentiality. In recognizing a cause of action for breach of the duty of confidentiality in the physician-patient relationship by improperly disclosing medical information, the Supreme Court cited case law in other states including Massachusetts, New York and New Jersey, as well as public policy.
After the most recent decision, the plaintiff’s lawyer, Bruce Elstein, said, “I don’t believe [the medical practice] knew what to do under HIPAA. They were inadequately trained and they did not even consult a manual prepared for them by a consultant on what to do when presented with a subpoena.” HIPAA requires that a healthcare provider train and periodically retrain its workforce.
The current judgment was for $853,000 which, with interest from 2007, will total approximately $2 million, but the defendant is expected to appeal the verdict to the Connecticut Appellate Court.
MORE NEWS ON HIPAA
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights (OCR) recently released an audit report on HIPAA...
Read MoreA proposed rule released by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services on December 10 would give healthcare providers...
Read MoreA recent article in Law360, “Bogus HIPAA Claims Are Flourishing As Pandemic Worsens,” discussed how the Covid-19 pandemic is fueling false...
Read More- ACOs
- Affordable Care Act
- Antitrust
- Behavioral Health
- Cannabis
- COVID-19
- Cybersecurity
- Electronic Health Records
- Employer/Employee
- False Claims Act
- FDA
- Fraud and Abuse
- HIPAA
- Home Health
- Hospitals
- Legislation and Public Policy
- Litigation
- Medical Devices and Wearables
- Medicare and Medicaid
- Nursing Homes
- Pharmaceuticals
- Private Insurers
- Tax/IRS
- Telehealth
December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 November 2018 October 2018
- ACOs
- Affordable Care Act
- Antitrust
- Behavioral Health
- Cannabis
- COVID-19
- Cybersecurity
- Electronic Health Records
- Employer/Employee
- False Claims Act
- FDA
- Fraud and Abuse
- HIPAA
- Home Health
- Hospitals
- Legislation and Public Policy
- Litigation
- Medical Devices and Wearables
- Medicare and Medicaid
- Nursing Homes
- Pharmaceuticals
- Private Insurers
- Tax/IRS
- Telehealth
- Jennifer Abreu
- Brian R. Ade
- Ashley (Osadon) Algazi
- Mary Aperance
- Steven J. Auletta
- Michael A.L. Balboni
- Khoren Bandazian
- Brian L. Bank
- Angelica M. Barcsansky
- Dion K. Bass
- Jill F. Bechtold
- Yonatan Bernstein
- Christina M. Bezas
- Michelle A. Bholan
- Jason M. Biegel
- Merril S. Biscone
- Jonah H. Blumenthal
- Stuart M. Bodoff
- Jann Brent
- Jonathan B. Bruno
- Andrew Buonincontri
- Jacqueline (Mecchella) Bushwack
- Curtis Campbell
- Michael C. Cannata
- David Cano
- Michele Chavez
- Kathryn Schulz Ches
- Margarita Christoforou
- Angela Cipolla
- Jill S. Citron
- Brian S. Conneely
- Sal Coppolino
- William Cornachio
- E.K. Cottrell
- Alexandra Cusano
- Melissa A. Dearing
- Nancy A. Del Pizzo
- Catalina E. De La Hoz
- Thomas V. DeMarco
- Joseph P. DiBella
- Janice J. DiGennaro
- Christine DiGregorio
- John K. Diviney
- Andrew Dugué
- Alan C. Eagle
- Glenn H. Egor
- Jeffrey Ehrhardt
- Daniel Ehrlich
- Scott A. Eisenmesser
- Karen Eng
- Joanne M. Engeldrum
- Harvey S. Epstein
- Eric D. Fader
- Brian L. Feld
- Scott L. Feuer
- Gary Fields
- James R. Finn
- Kaitlyn E. Flynn
- Robert Fogarty
- Richard A. Frankel
- Daniel E. Furshpan
- Avigael C. Fyman
- Jenna Z. Gabay
- Max Gershenoff
- Caitlyn Gibbons
- Laura (Mulholland) Gindele
- David Gise
- Maureen A. Glackin
- Erez Glambosky
- Ryan Goldberg
- Timothy Gonzalez
- Stuart I. Gordon
- Paul Gorfinkel
- Sean Gorton
- Joshua Gostel
- Joel M. Greenberg
- Jeffrey S. Greener
- David M. Grill
- Colin S. Grimm
- Amanda Griner
- Keith S. Grover
- Walter J. Gumersell
- Jason B. Gurdus
- Lawrence S. Han
- Qasim Haq
- Tamika N. Hardy
- Jean A. Hegler
- Amanda Hegyes
- Michael J. Heller
- Steven T. Henesy
- Katherine A. Heptig
- Jennifer F. Hillman
- Brandi Holton
- Claudia Honan (Hinrichsen)
- Jeremy B. Honig
- Robert Hussar
- Ryan T. Hyde
- Michael N. Impellizeri
- Megan Iocco
- Deborah M. Isaacson
- Robert H. Iseman
- Frank P. Izzo
- B. Edward Jaffe
- Ada Janocinska
- Michael J. Jones
- Geoffrey R. Kaiser
- Priscilla D. Kam
- Gene Y. Kang
- Konstantinos Kapatos
- Bernadette Kasnicki
- Jay D. Kenigsberg
- Cheryl F. Korman
- Yaron J. Kornblum
- Michael A. Kotula
- Drew Krieger
- Evan H. Krinick
- Christopher J. Kutner
- Joseph T. La Ferlita
- Katie Lachter
- Matthew A. Lampert
- Marie A. Landsman
- Carol A. Lastorino
- Jennifer P. Lawson
- Jessica Lefebvre
- Stella Lellos
- Barry I. Levy
- Lawrence A. Levy
- Cari Lewis
- David Lobl
- Paul V. Majkowski
- Edwin A. Maldonado
- Benjamin P. Malerba
- Robert A. Maloney
- Christopher Mango
- Greg E. Mann
- Patricia C. Marcin
- John Marino
- Henry M. Mascia
- Rebecca Matthews
- John M. McFaul
- Gloria J. Medina
- Douglas E. Menikheim
- Howard M. Merkrebs
- Silvana Merlino
- Heather S. Milanese
- Jamie (Eliassaint) Milfort
- Gregory D. Miller
- Siobhain P. Minarovich
- Frank M. Misiti
- Morgan Moceyunas
- Nicholas G. Moneta
- Rebecca Morrison
- Dylan Mruczinski
- John P. Mulvaney
- Kenneth C. Murphy
- E. Christopher Murray
- Anne M. Murray
- Philip Nash
- Mirielle Nezamy
- Kenneth A. Novikoff
- Colleen A. O’Neil
- Moise A. Ogé
- Chloe Orta
- John Panagopoulos
- Cristina M. Paneque
- Alexander G. Pappas
- Ana Parikh
- Domenick J. Pesce
- Albert W. Petraglia
- Jenna M. Pettograsso
- Justin M. Piccione
- Joseph Pidel
- Eric J. Ploumis
- Ashley Prinz
- Sheila Pugliese
- John F. Queenan
- Evan Rabinowitz
- Frank Raia
- Bryan Ramdat
- Ivette Reyes
- Gisella Rivera
- Pia E. Riverso
- John J. Robertelli
- Ryan Roberts
- Joanna B. Rosenblatt
- Burton R. Ross
- Lauren E. Russo
- Jeffrey P. Rust
- Alan S. Rutkin
- Andrea C. Sacks
- Jason A. Sanders
- David Santana
- Eric Santos
- Mariann Sarraf
- William M. Savino
- Catherine Savio
- Evan R. Schieber
- William Schleifer
- Brian S. Schlosser
- Michael Schnepper
- Thomas P. Schulz
- Paul Schwabe
- Garin Scollan
- Steven Shapiro
- Sahil Sharma
- Wendy Hoey Sheinberg
- Syma Shulman Levine
- Amy L. Silver
- Sean N. Simensky
- Avi Sinensky
- Michael A. Sirignano
- Stephen J. Smirti, Jr.
- Ariane Smith
- Joshua D. Smith
- Joseph N. Salomon
- Karen E. Sosler
- Matthew V. Spero
- Allison N. Stapleton
- Eric S. Strober
- James Suozzo
- Joshua M. Tare
- Stanley J. Tartaglia, Jr.
- Jonathan Tilles
- Frank P. Tiscione
- Alexandria E. Tomanelli
- Michael A. Troisi
- Lindsey R. Trowell
- Robert Tugander
- Michael J. Twersky
- Nadia Udeshi
- Marc S. Ullman
- Frank A. Valverde
- Michael Vanunu
- Michael P. Versichelli
- Louis Vlahos
- Jenson Wang
- Michael P. Welch
- Kristen L. Wenger
- Jefferson Wheeler
- Amy S. Wiedmann
- David S. Wilck
- Andrew L. Williams
- Benjamin J. Wisher
- Alexandra Wolff
- Matthew J. Zangwill
- Victoria Zorovich
- Steven M. Zuckermann
- Rivkin Rounds Staff
- Author Test