HHS Finalizes Civil Rights and Anti-Discrimination Rule
June 16, 2020 | Ada Janocinska | Affordable Care Act | Hospitals | Legislation and Public PolicyThe U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has finalized a new rule under Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act in an effort to enforce civil rights laws and protect against discrimination in healthcare. The rule, entitled “Nondiscrimination in Health and Health Education Programs or Activities: Delegation of Authority,” attempts to restore civil rights protections established under Section 1557 and resolve certain issues with prior HHS rulemaking that were highly scrutinized.
Section 1557 prohibits covered healthcare entities from discriminating on the basis of race, color, national origin, disability, age or sex. In 2016, the previous HHS administration issued a rule that redefined discrimination on the basis of sex to include termination of pregnancy and gender identity. The rule was challenged in federal courts, which concluded that HHS exceeded the scope of authority delegated to it by Congress under Section 1557 and that the proposed definition of sex discrimination was overly broad and contrary to applicable civil rights laws. Based on the court rulings, the new rule issued by HHS returns to the plain meaning of the word “sex” and interprets sex discrimination as discrimination on the basis that someone is male or female, as determined by biology. It should be noted that neither the 2016 rule nor the new rule recognizes sexual orientation as a protected category under Section 1557.
The new rule also maintains certain anti-discrimination protections that were first established in the 2016 rule. These include the requirement that healthcare facilities have appropriate physical access for individuals with disabilities, communication technology for individuals who are visually or hearing impaired, and translation and interpretation services for non-English speakers.
One requirement from the 2016 rule that was eliminated in the new rule is the requirement that healthcare facilities provide patients with non-discrimination notices and taglines in 15 or more languages. The notice and taglines had to be included in all “significant communications” to patients. It was concluded that this notice and tagline requirement was excessive and did not meaningfully accomplish its intended purpose, which was to promote access to care for non-English speakers, and that the costs of compliance were being passed down to patients. HHS estimates that eliminating the requirement will save Americans approximately $2.9 billion over the next 5 years.
Healthcare entities covered under Section 1557 must continue to provide written assurances to HHS that they are complying with the provisions of the final rule and Section 1557, and HHS will continue to enforce any non-compliance.
- ACOs
- Affordable Care Act
- Antitrust
- Behavioral Health
- Cannabis
- COVID-19
- Cybersecurity
- Electronic Health Records
- Employer/Employee
- False Claims Act
- FDA
- Fraud and Abuse
- HIPAA
- Home Health
- Hospitals
- Legislation and Public Policy
- Litigation
- Medical Devices and Wearables
- Medicare and Medicaid
- Nursing Homes
- Pharmaceuticals
- Private Insurers
- Tax/IRS
- Telehealth
December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 January 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 November 2018 October 2018
- ACOs
- Affordable Care Act
- Antitrust
- Behavioral Health
- Cannabis
- COVID-19
- Cybersecurity
- Electronic Health Records
- Employer/Employee
- False Claims Act
- FDA
- Fraud and Abuse
- HIPAA
- Home Health
- Hospitals
- Legislation and Public Policy
- Litigation
- Medical Devices and Wearables
- Medicare and Medicaid
- Nursing Homes
- Pharmaceuticals
- Private Insurers
- Tax/IRS
- Telehealth
- Jennifer Abreu
- Brian R. Ade
- Ashley Algazi
- Michael J. Antongiovanni
- Mary Aperance
- Krystal B. Armstrong
- Brian L. Bank
- Brandon Barbaruolo
- Dion K. Bass
- Jill F. Bechtold
- Joshua Beckham
- Andrew Berks
- Christina M. Bezas
- Samantha T. Bibbo
- Jason M. Biegel
- Merril S. Biscone
- Alexander Blisko
- Patricia Bober
- Stuart M. Bodoff
- Lindsay M. Brocki
- Jonathan B. Bruno
- Jordan Bryant
- Jacqueline (Mecchella) Bushwack
- Michael C. Cannata
- David Cano
- Caitlin S. Cash
- Michele Chavez
- Kathryn Schulz Ches
- Kaitlyn B. Connor
- Sal Coppolino
- William Cornachio
- E.K. Cottrell
- Wayne M. Cox
- James P. Cronin
- Alexandra Cusano
- Brendan Dakin
- Melissa A. Dearing
- Nancy A. Del Pizzo
- Catalina E. De La Hoz
- Janice J. DiGennaro
- Christine DiGregorio
- John K. Diviney
- AbiDemi M. Donovan
- Amanda B. Drantch
- Yadira Duran
- Glenn H. Egor
- Jeffrey Ehrhardt
- Daniel Ehrlich
- Scott A. Eisenmesser
- Karen Eng
- Joanne M. Engeldrum
- Harvey S. Epstein
- Eric D. Fader
- Brian L. Feld
- Scott L. Feuer
- John Ficarra
- Gary Fields
- James R. Finn
- Kaitlyn E. Flynn
- Kate Fohrkolb
- Gabrielle Fromer
- Daniel E. Furshpan
- Avigael C. Fyman
- Jenna Z. Gabay
- Max Gershenoff
- Caitlyn Gibbons
- Laura (Mulholland) Gindele
- Maureen A. Glackin
- Erez Glambosky
- Ryan Goldberg
- Tim Gonzalez
- Stuart I. Gordon
- Paul Gorfinkel
- Sean Gorton
- Wallis L. Granat
- Joel M. Greenberg
- Jeffrey S. Greener
- David M. Grill
- Amanda Griner
- Keith S. Grover
- Walter J. Gumersell
- Lawrence S. Han
- Mohammed Haque
- Tamika N. Hardy
- Rosemary Harnisher
- Anthony Hawkins
- Nicole Hecker
- Jean A. Hegler
- Michael J. Heller
- Steven T. Henesy
- Peter Henninger
- Katherine A. Heptig
- Jennifer F. Hillman
- Brandi Holton
- Claudia Honan (Hinrichsen)
- Jeremy B. Honig
- Ryan T. Hyde
- Michael N. Impellizeri
- Deborah M. Isaacson
- Robert H. Iseman
- Louis T. Iturra
- Frank P. Izzo
- B. Edward Jaffe
- Rawson Jahan
- Ada Janocinska
- Katherine Jenkins
- Michael J. Jones
- Atara Kahn
- Geoffrey R. Kaiser
- Gene Y. Kang
- Bernadette Kasnicki
- Ari Katzap
- Jay D. Kenigsberg
- Beyza Killeen
- Elan Kirshenbaum
- Michelle (Bholan) Klein
- Cheryl F. Korman
- Yaron J. Kornblum
- Michael A. Kotula
- Drew Krieger
- Evan H. Krinick
- Christopher J. Kutner
- Joseph T. La Ferlita
- Katie Lachter
- Katherine Lalor
- Matthew A. Lampert
- Marie A. Landsman
- Carol A. Lastorino
- Melissa K. Lee
- Jessica Lefebvre
- Stella Lellos
- Alexander Lev
- Barry I. Levy
- Lawrence A. Levy
- Cari Lewis
- Royce Liu
- David Lobl
- Jessica Flores Lynch
- Paul V. Majkowski
- Edwin A. Maldonado
- Benjamin P. Malerba
- Robert A. Maloney
- Christopher Mango
- Greg E. Mann
- Emily E. Manning
- Harini Maragh
- Patricia C. Marcin
- John Marino
- Henry M. Mascia
- Rebecca Matthews
- John M. McFaul
- Lauren I. Mechaly
- Douglas E. Menikheim
- Silvana Merlino
- Jamie (Eliassaint) Milfort
- Gregory D. Miller
- Morgan Miller
- Frank M. Misiti
- Morgan Moceyunas
- Nicholas G. Moneta
- Rebecca Morrison
- Dylan Mruczinski
- John P. Mulvaney
- Kenneth C. Murphy
- Anne M. Murray
- E. Christopher Murray
- Philip P. Nash
- James E. Nelson
- Mirielle Nezamy
- Kenneth A. Novikoff
- Moise A. Ogé
- Chloe Orta
- Thomas Paddock
- John Panagopoulos
- Michael F. Panayotou
- Alexander G. Pappas
- Alexa Pappas
- Ana Parikh
- Felicia Pasculli
- Justin S. Penchuk
- Domenick J. Pesce
- Albert W. Petraglia
- Jenna M. Pettograsso
- Joseph Pidel
- Eric J. Ploumis
- Ashley Prinz
- Sheila Pugliese
- John F. Queenan
- Evan Rabinowitz
- Frank Raia
- Gisella Rivera
- Pia E. Riverso
- Joanna B. Rosenblatt
- Burton R. Ross
- Timothy J. Ross
- Alex R. Rukab
- Lauren E. Russo
- Jeffrey P. Rust
- Alan S. Rutkin
- Andrea C. Sacks
- Catherine Salerno
- Eric Santos
- William M. Savino
- Catherine Savio
- Evan R. Schieber
- William Schleifer
- Brian S. Schlosser
- Michael Schnepper
- Thomas P. Schulz
- Paul Schwabe
- Garin Scollan
- Spencer Serling
- Steven Shapiro
- Sahil Sharma
- Wendy Hoey Sheinberg
- Syma Shulman Levine
- Amy L. Silver
- Sean N. Simensky
- Avi Sinensky
- Jaana Singh
- Michael A. Sirignano
- Joshua D. Smith
- Ariane Smith
- Joseph N. Salomon
- Karen E. Sosler
- Matthew V. Spero
- Levi P. Stoep
- Eric S. Strober
- James Suozzo
- Elizabeth S. Sy
- Joshua M. Tare
- Stanley J. Tartaglia, Jr.
- Jonathan Tilles
- Frank P. Tiscione
- Norton L. Travis
- Michael A. Troisi
- Lindsey R. Trowell
- Robert Tugander
- Nadia Udeshi
- Marc S. Ullman
- Frank A. Valverde
- Michael Vanunu
- Michael P. Versichelli
- Louis Vlahos
- Michael P. Welch
- Kristen L. Wenger
- Kyle W. White
- Amy S. Wiedmann
- David S. Wilck
- Jessica J. Williams
- Benjamin J. Wisher
- Thomas P. Wolowski
- Rebecca Yin
- Stephanie C. Zaferiou
- Matthew J. Zangwill
- Aaron E. Zerykier
- Victoria Zorovich
- Steven M. Zuckermann
- Rivkin Rounds Staff
- Author Test