“Factually False” Billings are Sufficient Basis for FCA Action
November 5, 2018 | Geoffrey R. Kaiser | False Claims Act | Fraud and Abuse | Litigation | Medicare and MedicaidA federal district court in Illinois, in United States ex rel. Morgan v. Champion Fitness, Inc. et al., No. 1:13-cv-1593 (C.D. Ill, October 19, 2018), recently considered whether the materiality requirement set forth by the U.S. Supreme Court in Universal Health Servs., Inc. v. United States and Massachusetts, ex rel. Escobar, 136 S. Ct. 1989 (2016) applies outside the context of “implied false certification” claims under the False Claims Act (FCA).
In Escobar, the High Court articulated a rigorous concept of materiality to be applied in “implied false certification” cases, ruling that FCA liability will turn on whether an alleged misrepresentation regarding compliance with a statutory, regulatory or contractual requirement (a type of “legal falsity”) was material to the government’s payment decision. In the Morgan case, the District Court considered a motion to dismiss a whistleblower’s allegations that the defendants billed Medicare for physical therapy services that were not actually rendered, as evidenced by billing purporting to show a therapist providing therapy to two patients in two locations simultaneously. The defendants argued that Escobar’s materiality requirement applied because the relator allegedly asserted an “implied false certification” theory.
The Court rejected this reasoning, concluding that the relator was not asserting a “legally false” claim, but rather a “factually false” claim based on billings for services that were not actually rendered. The Court observed that “the materiality standard may or may not apply in cases where factually false claims are alleged,” but that it really did not matter in this case because the Court could not conceive of anything “more material than whether or not services were provided” and that “it is unsurprisingly clear that the Government only intends to reimburse therapists for physical therapy actually performed.”
MORE NEWS ON False Claims Act
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) announced on November 15 that Sutter Health, a northern California health system, agreed to pay...
Read MoreSpinal implant manufacturer Life Spine Inc. and two of its executives have settled their False Claims Act case by agreeing...
Read MoreThe U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) announced on October 28 that Sanford Health, a hospital in Sioux Falls, South Dakota,...
Read More- Affordable Care Act
- Antitrust
- Cannabis
- Cybersecurity
- Electronic Health Records
- Employer/Employee
- False Claims Act
- FDA
- Fraud and Abuse
- HIPAA
- Home Health
- Hospitals
- Legislation and Public Policy
- Litigation
- Medical Devices and Wearables
- Medicare and Medicaid
- Pharmaceuticals
- Private Insurers
- Tax/IRS
- Telehealth
- Affordable Care Act
- Antitrust
- Cannabis
- Cybersecurity
- Electronic Health Records
- Employer/Employee
- False Claims Act
- FDA
- Fraud and Abuse
- HIPAA
- Home Health
- Hospitals
- Legislation and Public Policy
- Litigation
- Medical Devices and Wearables
- Medicare and Medicaid
- Pharmaceuticals
- Private Insurers
- Tax/IRS
- Telehealth
- Jennifer Abreu
- Christopher D. Acosta
- Brian R. Ade
- Ashley (Osadon) Algazi
- Donald R. Allard
- Mark N. Antar
- Patrick E. Antonikowski
- Steven J. Auletta
- Michael A.L. Balboni
- Khoren Bandazian
- Timothy J. Bang
- Brian L. Bank
- Nicholas P. Baran
- Angelica M. Barcsansky
- Noah M. Becker
- Todd Belous
- Bruce A. Bendix
- Yonatan Bernstein
- Christina M. Bezas
- Michelle A. Bholan
- Merril S. Biscone
- Stuart M. Bodoff
- J’Naia L. Boyd
- Jonathan B. Bruno
- Jacqueline (Mecchella) Bushwack
- John P. Campana
- Michael C. Cannata
- Margarita Christoforou
- Brian S. Conneely
- Peter C. Contino
- William Cornachio
- Michael J. Cunningham
- Louis D`Amaro
- George K. DeHaven
- Catalina E. De La Hoz
- Nancy A. Del Pizzo
- Thomas V. DeMarco
- Janice J. DiGennaro
- Christine DiGregorio
- Cassandra Rivais DiNova
- John K. Diviney
- Alan C. Eagle
- Glenn H. Egor
- Scott A. Eisenmesser
- Joanne M. Engeldrum
- Andrew S. Epstein
- Harvey S. Epstein
- Eric D. Fader
- Ade A. Famojuro
- Jeannine M. Farino
- Brian L. Feld
- Scott L. Feuer
- James R. Finn
- Kaitlyn E. Flynn
- Matthew D. Fox
- Richard A. Frankel
- Avigael C. Fyman
- Jenna Z. Gabay
- Anthony R. Gambardella
- Max Gershenoff
- Frank J. Giliberti
- David I. Gise
- Erez Glambosky
- Ryan Goldberg
- Stacey L. Goldstein
- Jeffrey P. Gorak
- Stuart I. Gordon
- Paul Gorfinkel
- Sean Gorton
- Jeffrey S. Greener
- David M. Grill
- Keith S. Grover
- Walter J. Gumersell
- Jason B. Gurdus
- Amanda Gurman
- Penny Hahn
- Lawrence S. Han
- Tamika Hardy
- Michael J. Heller
- Steven T. Henesy
- Katherine A. Heptig
- Claudia Hinrichsen
- Frank Holahan
- Jeremy B. Honig
- Carol A. Hyde
- Deborah M. Isaacson
- Robert H. Iseman
- Frank P. Izzo
- B. Edward Jaffe
- Michael J. Jones
- Geoffrey R. Kaiser
- Priscilla D. Kam
- Gene Y. Kang
- George D. Kappus
- Jay D. Kenigsberg
- Robert C. Kern, Jr.
- Donald Kernisant Jr.
- Cheryl F. Korman
- Yaron J. Kornblum
- Michael A. Kotula
- Ada Kozicz
- Evan H. Krinick
- Jason M. Kurland
- Christopher J. Kutner
- James P. Lagios
- Matthew A. Lampert
- Marie A. Landsman
- Carol A. Lastorino
- Yale A. Leber
- Stella Lellos
- David P. Leno
- Alexander Lev
- Barry I. Levy
- Lawrence A. Levy
- Shari Claire Lewis
- David Lobl
- Ora L. Lupear
- Paul V. Majkowski
- Benjamin P. Malerba
- Robert A. Maloney
- Greg E. Mann
- Henry M. Mascia
- John M. McFaul
- Peter P. McNamara
- Howard M. Merkrebs
- Steven R. Miller
- Gregory D. Miller
- Siobhain P. Minarovich
- Frank M. Misiti
- Michael C. Mulè
- Laura J. Mulholland
- John P. Mulvaney
- Kenneth C. Murphy
- Jeffrey M. Murphy
- Anne M. Murray
- Philip Nash
- Kenneth A. Novikoff
- Patrick R. O`Mea
- Colleen A. O’Neil
- Julie Ovicher
- John Panagopoulos
- Alexander G. Pappas
- Ana Parikh
- Janine L. Peress
- Michelle Peretz
- Albert W. Petraglia
- Jenna M. Pettograsso
- Justin M. Piccione
- Vincent J. Pontrello
- Lisa Bordoff Procopio
- John F. Queenan
- Evan Rabinowitz
- Frank Raia
- David E. Richman
- Michele R. Rita
- Pia E. Riverso
- John L. Rivkin
- Leonard L. Rivkin
- John J. Robertelli
- Jason M. Romeo
- Burton R. Ross
- Michael R. Rudick
- Jeffrey P. Rust
- Alan S. Rutkin
- Andrea C. Sacks
- Eric Santos
- Keegan B. Sapp
- William M. Savino
- Evan R. Schieber
- Brian S. Schlosser
- Michael Schnepper
- Thomas P. Schulz
- Garin Scollan
- Steven Shapiro
- Wendy Hoey Sheinberg
- Joshua D. Sibble
- Sean N. Simensky
- Michael A. Sirignano
- Stephen J. Smirti, Jr.
- Joshua D. Smith
- Joseph N. Salomon
- Karen E. Sosler
- Matthew V. Spero
- Eric S. Strober
- Joshua M. Tare
- Stanley J. Tartaglia, Jr.
- Frank P. Tiscione
- Norman L. Tolle
- Michael A. Troisi
- Robert Tugander
- Michael J. Twersky
- Marc S. Ullman
- Frank A. Valverde
- Michael Vanunu
- Michael P. Versichelli
- Mark J. Wagner Jr.
- Stephen B. Weissman
- Michael P. Welch
- Amy S. Wiedmann
- David S. Wilck
- Dennis Wiley
- Andrew L. Williams
- Steven M. Zuckermann
- Alexander Zugaro
- Rivkin Rounds Staff
- Author Test